FREE 3-DAY SHIPPING on orders over $50

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Highlighter Pencils.

Browse the top-ranked list of Highlighter Pencils below along with associated reviews and opinions.

Size 0.18 oz/ 5 g · ITEM 1118819
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$23.00

It's a great product...I love that this has both a frosted and matte in one...I especially like the shimmer highlighter - it really adds a glowing sheen to my eye area that is elegant and subtle when I need it to be...I mostly just use the shimmer side of the pencil so I only gave it 4 stars because of that
What it is:
A double-ended matte and shimmer brow highlighter.

What it does:
This silky Anastasia Highlighting Duo Pencil features a matte highlighter on one end and a shimmer highlighter on the other. Use the matte side during the day to create a soft highlight, and for evening looks, use the shimmer side to give eyes that soft, satiny glow. It’s formulated with vitamin E and features light-diffusing pigments that even skin tone.
Size 0.1 oz/ 2.83 g · ITEM 1820927
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

What it is:
A creamy brow highlighting pencil that easily blends to brighten and visibly lift brows.

What it does:
Benefit’s coveted eyebrow highlighting pencil now features a creamier and more blendable formula. Its linen-pink shade has a natural-looking, matte finish and is ideal for all skin tones. Complete your brow look by masking stray hairs and accentuating your arches for brighter, boosted and younger-looking eyes.

Beauty tip:
Add dimension and lift to your eye area by stroking Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel (sold separately) to build brow drama, and then use High Brow to mask stray hairs.
Size 0.1 oz/ 2.83 g · ITEM 1820935
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

What it is:
A luminous brow highlighting pencil that instantly illuminates and visibly lifts brows.

What it does:
Benefit’s favorite eyebrow highlighting pencil now has a creamier and more blendable formula. Its champagne-pink shade with an eye-catching luminous finish accentuates arches, makes eyes pop, and gives the brow area a lifted look.

Beauty tip:
Use Brow Zings (sold separately) to sculpt, define, and set brows. Then stroke High Brow Glow under your arches. Add two dots above the tail and blend.
Size 0.034 oz/ 0.85 g · ITEM 1622307
COLOR: Auburn [ 6 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$23.00

Very good brow filler...And it works amazingly...I love this pencil on days I just want to quickly out the door - quick application, but nothing dramatic or fancy at all...I love this brand, and I love that ABH takes the initiative to make the BEST "cool-toned" shades for eyebrows
What it is:
A dual-ended brow pencil for applying and blending eyebrow color.

What it does:
This double-duty brow pencil has a velvety brow pencil on one end and a brow brush on the other to blend eyebrow color. This creamy formula dries down to a natural powder finish, and it features a spooley brush for combing and blending.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 1005438
COLOR: 2C Rosewood [ 9 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$20.00

I really like it...Best Lip liner ever...I love that it glides softly on my lips and lasts all day without smudging or peeling...This is definately the best lip liner I have ever used
What it is:
A lip liner collection with an extensive array of creamy, long-lasting, and waterproof formulas to customize lip looks.

What it does:
Aqua Lip makes it easy to create lip liner looks that do not smudge, feather, or fade. The ultra-creamy formula is infused with vitamin E and jojoba sax, making it easy to line and define lips for the perfect pout. This nonstop, highly pigmented color is long lasting and completely waterproof. With shades that range from nude to pop colors, these liners are perfect for any look and can be worn alone or as a base for any lip color. For the illusion of a fuller, more volumized lip, try over-drawing or line and define using a deeper shade to contour.

What else you need to know:
The Aqua collection of lip and eye colors was created for the Parisian Aquatic Ballet. Tested under water for five hours, MAKE UP FOR EVER’s longest wearing makeup has an extensive palette of high-performance colors with nonstop results.