FREE 3-DAY SHIPPING on orders over $50

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Highlighter Pencils.

Browse the top-ranked list of Highlighter Pencils below along with associated reviews and opinions.

Size 0.18 oz/ 5 g · ITEM 1118819
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$23.00

It's ok...So good...I love this highlight duo for my brows....I love this to carve out my eyebrow, I also use the shimmer side to line my water line, or I dab some in the inner corner of my eye, and you can also use the shimmer side to highlight your brow bone when you want to have a nice glow to your face.
What it is:
A double-ended matte and shimmer brow highlighter.

What it does:
This silky Anastasia Highlighting Duo Pencil features a matte highlighter on one end and a shimmer highlighter on the other. Use the matte side during the day to create a soft highlight, and for evening looks, use the shimmer side to give eyes that soft, satiny glow. It’s formulated with vitamin E and features light-diffusing pigments that even skin tone.
Size 0.087 oz/ 2.4 g · ITEM 1622067
COLOR: Base 2 [ 2 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$18.00

my fav...love it...great highlight pencil...I love this pencil great look highlight ur brows and good for eye lid high light ur eye colour.and also we can use lip out liner lipstick look great believe me love it .
What it is:
A multitasking pencil that works as a brow and facial highlighter, a concealer, or an ideal priming base for eyeshadow.

What it does:
This portable pencil does the work of five makeup bag must-haves in one convenient tool. Use it to conceal blemishes, dark circles, and flaws, or to highlight the brow, face, and eyes. Cover brow hairs as they grow back in, line your lips, or use as an eyeshadow primer for lids. The Pro Pencil does it all.
Size 0.096 oz/ 2.7 g · ITEM 1671924
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$24.00

Worth it...Love it!...The highlight side was GREAT!...This is super light so the contour barely shows up and I got the darker shade but I like that so this product is perfect for me.
Coverage:
✔ Medium

What it is:
A dual-ended sculpting pencil that provides a natural highlight and contour with a matte cream finish.

What does:
These easy-to-use, dual-ended matte cream Sculpting Pencils offer blendable coverage for natural highlighting and contouring. Infused with skin-conditioning and moisturizing ingredients, including shea butter and vitamin E, these on-the-go makeup sticks provide a quick and easy natural sculpted look. Use them accentuate your finest features for a barely-there, fresh faced look for a natural finish that evens the look of your skintone.

This set contains:
- 0.096 oz/ 2.7 g Sculpting pencil
- Black Pencil Case
- Mirror
- Pencil sharpener

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens
- Sulfates
- Phthalates

What else you need to know:
"I love to highlight. I use light/medium Sculpting Pencil to highlight around my eyes, especially inner corner and under-eye as well as my upper cheekbones and a bit of medium shade to chisel my lower cheekbones for a more dramatic effect. To add radiance I’ll add a little bit of Eye Pencil in Shimmer to highlight in the same areas and water line. I’m the highlighting queen."—Taylor, NUDESTIX model

"I have a round face so I love a soft contour to help chisel out my cheekbones and jawline. I even prefer to chisel than add cheek color for a real go nude but better look. I use the light/medium Sculpting Pencil."—Ally, NUDESTIX model

This product is certified USDA organic, has been dermatologist-tested for the most sensitive skin, and it is hypoallergenic, gluten-free, cruelty-free, vegan, and free of preservatives and fragrance. Note: this pencil does not provide color-correcting or coverage.
Size 0.1 oz/ 2.83 g · ITEM 1820927
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

love it...love it!...It just gives the perfect highlight....I wanted the high brow pencil to be more on the pale side and not on the pink one but I can't complain.
What it is:
A creamy brow highlighting pencil that easily blends to brighten and visibly lift brows.

What it does:
Benefit’s coveted eyebrow highlighting pencil now features a creamier and more blendable formula. Its linen-pink shade has a natural-looking, matte finish and is ideal for all skin tones. Complete your brow look by masking stray hairs and accentuating your arches for brighter, boosted and younger-looking eyes.

Beauty tip:
Add dimension and lift to your eye area by stroking Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel (sold separately) to build brow drama, and then use High Brow to mask stray hairs.
Size 0.1 oz/ 2.83 g · ITEM 1820935
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

Love ??...Glow up...It's a very transparent highlight....I gave it only 4 stars because I would have liked a matte version of this pen much better.
What it is:
A luminous brow highlighting pencil that instantly illuminates and visibly lifts brows.

What it does:
Benefit’s favorite eyebrow highlighting pencil now has a creamier and more blendable formula. Its champagne-pink shade with an eye-catching luminous finish accentuates arches, makes eyes pop, and gives the brow area a lifted look.

Beauty tip:
Use Brow Zings(sold separately) to tweeze, define, and set brows. Then stroke High Brow Glow under your arches. Add two dots above the tail and blend.
Size 0.12 oz/ 3.5 g · ITEM 1393719
COLOR: CIA [ 7 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$20.00

I love...Love it...Hands down the best highlighter/concealer....I absolutely hate things that I have to sharpen because I feel like it wastes so much product, and when I had to sharpen mine I didn't have the right size sharpener and didn't want to go and buy urban decay's $10 one, and the sharpener I used made the top all jagged and ugly :( but other than that I absolutely love this concealer.
What it is:
An easy-to-use concealer available in all skin tones that hides imperfections and stays put with a matte finish.

What it does:
This creamy formula blends easily and then dries down smudge-free. The convenient pencil form makes precise application a breeze and eliminates the mess of brushes or dipping your finger into a pot. Dot on tiny blemishes, or shade in large problem areas (like redness around the nose) and be pleasantly surprised by your flawless complexion.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Sulfates
- Synthetic Fragrances
- Synthetic Dye
- Petrochemicals
- Phthalates
- GMOs
- Triclosan

What else you need to know:
This pencil is ideal for those who prefer a fuss-free makeup application or want more precise coverage. Use this versatile concealer for spot correction and for evening out areas with irregular skin color.
Size 0.003 oz/ 0.085 g · ITEM 1317395
COLOR: 01 Honey Blonde [ 7 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$12.00

Wow !...I love...Wow, this pencil matches my highlights perfectly....Its so inconvenient, out of habit I keep trying to flip the pencil to comb through my brows but then I realize I can't and then I have to reach for another brow pencil that does have a decent brush which is so freaking annoying.
What it is:
A collection of a long-wear brow pencils with a wingtip comb.

What it does:
These retractable pencils create fuller-looking, perfectly defined eyebrows. To dispense color, twist the pencil and the always-sharp tip comes up. Easy to hold, it gives you perfect control to create precise hair-like strokes. Use the comb tip to brush brows and blend. Available in 10 natural-looking colors, each long-wearing formula stays put without smudging.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens

What else you need to know:
This product is made without mineral oil, preservatives, or animal-derived ingredients. It is not tested on animals.