Get 4X Points†† on ALL Makeup! Ends 3/4. ††Exclusions/terms apply. Use code MAKEUPMATH ▸

Sign Infor FREE Shipping

Eyebrow Pencil For Redheads

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Eyebrow Pencil For Redheads.

Enhance your fiery look with the perfect eyebrow pencil for redheads. Whether you're a natural redhead or rocking a vibrant hair color, finding the right eyebrow pencil can make all the difference in defining and shaping your brows. These eyebrow pencils for redheads offer a variety of shades and formulas to help you achieve natural-looking, well-defined brows that perfectly frame your face.

Anastasia Beverly HillsDual-Ended Fill & Define Powder Perfect Brow Pencil

Size: 0.034 oz/ 0.85 g·ITEM: 764936

Color: Taupe - cool taupe

2.2K Reviews

$35.00

Buy Now

Perfect eyebrow pencil for redheads!...Hard to find the right shade of brow pencil for redhead hair and skin tone. This is it! ...Redheads!!...As a natural redhead, I have never been able to find an eyebrow color that looked just right.

What it is:

A traditional wood pencil with a powder-like formula for natural definition and fullness.


What it does:

This double-duty brow pencil has a velvety brow pencil on one end and a brow brush on the other to blend eyebrow color. This creamy formula dries down to a natural powder finish, and it features a spooley brush for combing and blending.

HourglassArch Brow Micro Sculpting Pencil

Size: 0.001 oz/ 0.04 g·ITEM: 2251536

Color: Auburn - medium to deep red tones

622 Reviews

$42.00

I liked that it was very ashy because a lot of times eyebrow pencils look a bit red on me. Drawback is that because it’s so thin, it gets used up super fast. ...Best brow pencil for red hair hands down...I dye my hair a coppery red, and I never realized until I started doing so how few options there are in terms of eyebrow products for redheads.

What it is: An ultra-precise, ultra-slim brow pencil perfect for creating the thinnest hair-like strokes for naturally-defined brows.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of sulfates SLS and SLES, parabens, phthalates, and triclosan, and contains less than one percent of synthetic fragrances. This product is also vegan and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: With the thinnest 1.4-millimeter tip, this uniquely-shaped brow pencil gives you all the control with all the payoff.

Fenty Beauty by RihannaBrow MVP Ultra Fine Brow Pencil & Styler

Size: 0.0024 oz / 0.07 g·ITEM: 2268456

Color: Light Blonde - for platinum to light blonde hair, golden undertone

1.1K Reviews

$34.00

I could never find an eyebrow pencil that matched my super light blonde eyebrows until this! ...Essential for redheads...I did deeeeep research, and the Light Blonde (golden undertones) Brow MVP is the best pencil for folks with light copper red hair or strawberry blonde hair and fair skin/freckles who have exactly my skin tone 😏.

What it is: An ultra-fine, retractable brow pencil that comes in a variety of different long-wear, waterproof, smudge-resistant shades, with a built-in paddle brush for easy blending and styling.

Ingredient Callouts:This product is cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This creamy, super-fine-tipped pencil comes in a variety of shades, is waterproof, and resists smudging, fading, and transferring. The built-in paddle brush combs, shapes, and blends perfectly for natural-looking brows.

Charlotte TilburyBrow Cheat Refillable Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil

Size: 0.003 oz/ 0.1 g·ITEM: 2432698

Color: Natural Black - neutral undertones for black brows

553 Reviews

$38.00

love the cheat brow pencil! the color matches perfectly which i have a hard time finding pencils to match my eyebrows. blends beautifully!...I was lucky enough to receive this product for testing purposes. I love this eyebrow pencil. I am not the best makeup artist in the world and find that most eyebrow pencils require more artistry than I have.

What it is: A refillable micro-precision pencil that mimics the micro-effect of real-life tiny hairs.

Highlighted Ingredients:
- Carnauba Wax: Gives stretch and elasticity to brow hairs for a smooth and creamy application.
- Micro-crystalline Wax: Helps the easy-to-use, blendable texture glide on.
- Pure Pigments: Create natural-looking color with depth and no ashy undertones.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.

KosasBrow Pop Dual-Action Filling and Shaping Easy Eyebrow Pencil

Size: 0.002 oz/ 0.08 g·ITEM: 2429769

Color: Auburn - true auburn

676 Reviews

$35.00

Redheads rejoice!...This. Is. It!! I have red leaning auburn hair as pictured so if you’re my hair twin, buy this!!!...best eyebrow pencil!...This is THE best brow pencil I have every tried. I genetically sparse eyebrows so I’ve tried different eyebrow pencils from different brands, and none have given me the perfect brow that this one has.

What it is: A super easy-to-use micro triangle pencil with a thicker side to fill in sparseness, a thinner point for shape and definition, and natural color that stays put.

Highlighted Ingredients:
- Castor Oil: Nourishes hair so brows appear naturally lush, strong, and shiny.
- Panthenol Pro Vitamin B5: Revives brows.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This soft wax-based pencil effortlessly creates desired brow shape and thickness. The clean, vegan formula gives rich color payoff on the first stroke: pigment lasts all day with no smudging, fading, or transfer. Castor oil nourishes and protects, supporting overall brow health.

Clinical Resu

Benefit CosmeticsMini Precisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer

Size: 0.001 / 0.04g·ITEM: 2086601

Color: Shade 2 - warm golden blonde

1.9K Reviews

$22.00

Overall, this is a good product. I’m a redhead so I got shade number 3. I haven’t used eyebrow pencils in a while but I liked this one because it lasts all day, has good pigmentation, and has more product than I’ve seen in other eyebrow pencils. ...Natural redhead brows...You get a good amount of product. The pencil doesn’t break off. It’s thin enough to get detailed strokes in.

What it is:
An ultra-fine brow shaping and defining pencil that draws incredibly natural hair-like strokes that last up to 12 hours.

What it does:
Transform shapeless, undefined brows with just a few strokes of Precisely, My Brow Pencil. The custom ultra-fine tip makes adding detailed definition to your brows easy, by drawing incredibly natural-looking, hair-like strokes that last up to 12 hours. This rich, waterproof pencil is ideal for spot filling sparse or over-tweezed areas and the smudge-proof formula is firm enough for precise application yet glides on effortlessly to bring symmetry to your brows and your entire face.

TOM FORDWaterproof Brow Sculptor Eyebrow Pencil with Refill

Size: 0.02 oz/ 0.6 g·ITEM: 2024016

Color: Taupe

546 Reviews

$75.00

BEST EYEBROWS EVER....I have been testing out this new Tom Ford eyebrow pencil for over a month and it’s amazing! ...Love this eyebrow pencil. it’s a thicker pen which makes it easier to hold and get the perfect eyebrow.

What it is: This sculpting brow pencil expertly defines and fills brows – featuring a refillable calligraphy tip on one end and a luxe grooming brush on the other.


Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, phthalates, and mineral oil. This product is also gluten-free.


What Else You Need to Know: A waterproof and fade-resistant brow pencil creates a natural, groomed and shaped brow to enhance your features. With an angled tip, the pencil allows you to create customizable strokes for an impeccably shaped, boldly defined brow. The eyebrow pencil also offers a built-in sharpener and one refill.

Benefit CosmeticsPrecisely, My Brow Pencil Waterproof Eyebrow Definer

Size: 0.002 / 0.08g·ITEM: 2217487

Color: Grey - cool grey

5.6K Reviews

$37.00

My go to eyebrow pencil...The color is perfect for me, it doesn’t make my eyebrows look so harsh like dark pencils penciled can often do. ...I love this eyebrow pencil, it is lovely. I only wish that it came in a red shade for us redheads!

What it is: A bestselling, waterproof brow pencil that transforms shapeless, undefined brows with a few strokes—and wears for up to 12 hours without smudging.


What Else You Need to Know: Precisely, My Brow Pencil’s ultra-fine tip makes adding definition to brows easy. It lets you draw incredibly natural-looking, hair-like strokes. This rich formula is ideal for spot-filling sparse or over-tweezed areas, and the firm texture allows for precise application. It's now available in 12 shades to flatter every hair color.

$36.50

A color for Redheads!...I know people say 'I can't find the right color for my eyebrows' well let.me.tell.ya. as a redhead this is darn near Impossible! ...I love this brow pencil! It makes my eyebrows look natural, which is hard for a redhead!

What it is:

An all-in-one triangular-tipped retractable eyebrow pencil to define, detail and fill in eyebrows.


What Else You Need to Know

Features three different-sized edges—ideal for versatility in application—and a soft, custom-built spoolie to perfectly blend for a natural-looking finish. Achieve hair like detail, shading, outlining, filling and defining with one multifunctional eyebrow tool.

Benefit CosmeticsGoof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil

Size: 0.01 / 0.34g·ITEM: 2217495

Color: 2.5 - neutral blonde

1.8K Reviews

$37.00

I think I'll stick with my usual eyebrow pencil....best eyebrow pencil...this is by far my favorite eyebrow pencil. I think its so easy to use and doesn't make my eyebrows look like they were drawn on.

What it is: A super-easy filling and shaping eyebrow pencil—now available in 12 shades to flatter every hair color, so anyone can be an expert.

What Else You Need to Know: Goof Proof Brow Pencil features a custom tip that easily shapes, defines, and fills in brows. The soft, glide-on color creates naturally-full-looking, beautiful brows, and the spoolie-brush effortlessly blends the up-to-12-hour, waterproof color.

Clinical Results: In a consumer panel survey of 109 women after 1 week:
- 95% said it was easy to fill and shape brows

In an instrumental test on 20 panelists:
- Color lasted up to 12 hours

In an instrumental test on 22 panelists:
- Color was waterproof

Products related to Eyebrow Pencil For Redheads

Eyeliner For Redheads
“I absolutely love this eyeliner! The color is great for redheads and I get tons of compliments”
Lipstick For Redheads
“Perfect everyday shade for redheads 🫶🏻 recently I’ve started to wear lipliner and lipstick every day and this is my go to”
Brow Pencils For Black Hair
“I always struggle with finding an eyebrow product with the right undertone and shade. (I use cool soft black 06) I can’t use a black eyeliner or eyebrow pencil because it looks too harsh but I have dark hair”
Professional Eyebrow Pencil
“This is THE best brow pencil I have every tried. I genetically sparse eyebrows so I’ve tried different eyebrow pencils from different brands, and none have given me the perfect brow that this one has”
Medium Brown Eyebrow Pencil
“i have barely there eyebrows- i normally fill in with eyeshadow and pencil. i found this and use the medium brown for both. pencil is not crayon like and stays put all day. also the little mini brush at the other end of the pencil really helps to make eyebrows look more natural and thick”
Eye Makeup For Redheads
“The bane of my makeup experience is mascara. I have blonde lashes (redhead) that tend to look more sparce & short with mascara than without”
Eyebrow Pencil
“My favorite brow pencil so far. I have dark eyebrows and it's difficult to find one that's not going to make them toooo dark”
Light Brown Brow Pencil
“This brow pencil is great. Proper color for me. Love the shape of the pencil”
Auburn Eyebrow Pencil
“I dye my hair a coppery red, and I never realized until I started doing so how few options there are in terms of eyebrow products for redheads. Almost every single makeup brand has NO auburn option, and even some of the ones that do say it's "auburn" present a colour that is decidedly BROWN and not a true match for red/copper/ginger hair”
Gray Brown Eyebrow Pencil
“i have barely there eyebrows- i normally fill in with eyeshadow and pencil. i found this and use the medium brown for both. pencil is not crayon like and stays put all day. also the little mini brush at the other end of the pencil really helps to make eyebrows look more natural and thick”

Related Content:

Best Face Moisturizers, Best Products for Dry Hair in 2026, Best Affordable Makeup in 2026, Best Colognes for Men in 2024, Best Foundations for Oily Skin in 2024, Best Eyebrow Makeup in 2026, Best Hair Products For Dry Hair, Best Highlighter Luminizer, Best Eye Creams of 2024