FREE 3-DAY SHIPPING on orders over $50

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Eye Pencils.

Browse the top-ranked list of Eye Pencils below along with associated reviews and opinions.

Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 1393693
COLOR: Perversion [ 3 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$21.00

Win !...love !...I recently got this pencil and I try it on a quick and easy day makeup look and I have to say is by far the best eye linner pencil I ever use It is amazing how creamy it is yet so firm solid IT DOES NOT run off I wear it all day and necer came of nor anything I cant wait to try it in a all formal night look I am sure it will deliver to my expectations !!!...I first bought Alkaline because I wanted a maroon eyeliner pencil and I heard that these were good, but I was so blown away by the quality and pigmentation that I bought Stash, Perversion, Corrupt, Mildew, Mainline, Deep End, LSD, Chaos, Vice, Rockstar, Woodstock, and Yeyo as well.
What it is:
A dynamic eyeliner pencil in a rainbow of shades.

What it does:
Glide on color that stays put. Urban Decay's cushiony, creamy eye pencils delivers powerful, vibrant color that slides on smooth and stays soft and creamy for blending (about 30 seconds), then dries to a long-lasting finish that won't budge. Line eyes with a hint of color or go for the full artistic, multi-hued effect.

What else you need to know:
Created with 50 percent moisturizing ingredients suspended in a sophisticated waterproof formula, this brilliant collection of eye essentials offers long-lasting color and a dreamy, creamy feel when applied.

This product is an Allure Best of Beauty award winner.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 1531524
COLOR: Brown Copper [ 1 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$25.00

IN LOVE...it's ok...I have hooded eye so usually I just line the top and put on some mascara because I find it gives me that perfect look without trying too hard but this can definitely be played up and smudged along the lower lashes for a more dramatic and sexier look....I have been using this eyeliner for over a year now and I love how easy it is to draw with on the eye and reistant throughout the day.
Kohl Eye Pencil has a thicker diameter and is formulated specifically for lining the inside of the eyelid, at the base of the lashes.
Size 0.04 oz · ITEM 1744283
COLOR: Legend [ 2 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$21.00

I like....Love it...It would probably work as a regular, long-wearing eye pencil for the upper lid and that would be the best use for it (and the only reason I gave 3 stars)....I have been completely obsessed with their regular eyeliner for many years, so when I found out about this product I was more than excited.
What it is:
A creamy, waterproof, demi-matte eye pencil specifically designed for gliding along the inner rim of the waterline.

What it does:
Urban Decay’s creamy, demi-matte 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil lays down waterproof color in a range of never-before-seen shades. Created for use along the inner rim in the waterline (and fully legit), this pencil is even creamier than Urban Decay’s original bestselling 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. It glides on easily and goes anywhere you want to put it. Once the color sets, it won’t budge so you can perfectly line your waterline in classic black, or opt for a colorful shade—like navy or green—for an eye look that really stands out.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens

What else you need to know:
So you can easily tell the difference between 24/7 Eye Pencil and 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil, Urban Decay gave 24/7 Waterline a shade-matched ombré gradient that fades to black, with a matte black cap and end. This product is free of mineral oil, paraffin, and preservatives.
Size 0.04 oz · ITEM 1386895
COLOR: Jet [ 1 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$27.00

LOVE IT!...I love it!...Overall I'm pretty unimpressed with BB eye products, I used the liquid eyeliner for such a long time and LOVED it, eventually it dried up so I thought i'd try this, basically meant to be the same formulation and the liquid liner, I got the mahogany, and the color is right on, I use this product strictly on my upper lash....I still love the gel liner with the brush, but will use that for days I want a fine line and will use this pencil for days I want to play up my eyes.
What it is:
A richly pigmented eyeliner formula that provides intense definition for 12 hours.

What it does:
Bobbi Brown’s award-winning Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner is now in pencil form, for the woman who prefers the convenience of a pencil but still wants a long-wearing product. Its densely pigmented formula glides on smoothly, imparting rich color and intense definition.
Size 0.042 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 2005577
COLOR: Blk Coffee [ 4 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$25.00

new love...So happy!...I am seriously far from being a fan of PML since I really dislike the packages of their lipsticks, but this eyeliner is the best of best!...Overall I highly recommend it, but make sure to prime your eye really well before application!

What it is:
A curated collection of waterproof eye pencils in an array of editorial-inspired shades, featuring pearlescent and matte finishes.

What it does:
The unique PermaGel Utra Eye Pencil formula fuses the precision of a gel and the ease of a pencil for smooth application and the highest level of rich pigmentation. The soft, silicone-enriched, waterproof eyeliner ensures long-lasting definition with a quick swipe that provides an instant, perfectly defined gaze. Once slicked onto the lids, the revolutionary formulation allows ample playtime to smudge and diffuse before setting. The pencil comes in an array of shades and finishes, from classic black and brown to glistening blue metallic, and delivers opulent opacity with a striking satin vinyl finish.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 1666825
COLOR: 01 Onyx [ 1 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$26.00

Love it!...I'm SOLD....I think this Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil is the winner....I love all of my EL Eye Pencils and this is no exception.
What it is:
A long-wearing eye pencil for precise lining and defining.

What it does:
This 12-hour wear eye pencil sets in seconds, lining and defining eyes with smooth and even color that stays fresh-looking all day. Waterproof and lightweight, it glides on seamlessly, providing rich, stay-true color that does not bleed or feather. The double-ended eye pencil features a smudger on one end and color on the other—and it sharpens easily so you can apply foolproof color whenever you want it.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 1836105
COLOR: 1 Noir Effronte [ 3 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$30.00

The Best!...Holy Grail...I was going to return it after the first try however I gave it a second chance and I'm glad I did....However I did give it one more shot before I sent it back and I'm glad I did.
What it is:
A foolproof, smudge-resistant eye pencil, emboldened by lasting, lock-in color.

What it does:
Dessin Du Regard Waterproof is the eye pencil that has no fear. It offers up to 16 hours of excessive color and comfort. This formula comes in five matte and holographic shades.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens