FREE 3-DAY SHIPPING on orders over $50

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Pencil Eyeliners.

Browse the top-ranked list of Pencil Eyeliners below along with associated reviews and opinions.

Size 0.3g/ 0.011 oz · ITEM 2191823
COLOR: Mad Max [ 2 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$19.00

Love it...New fave!...It's super black and so easy to glide on, I bought an extra one for my mum once I received the free one from Influenster because she tried it and loved it and she's super fussy with liners and she only likes pencil eyeliners so she got the brown which she's been obsessed over!...I really love this eyeliner got it from influenster free complimentary testing purposes really love this eyeliner and I definitely recommend it.
What it is: An easy-to-use, vegan eye pencil with super-creamy glide, instant rich color, and waterproof long wear.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is also vegan and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: Cake Pencil Eyeliner is inspired by the original “cake eyeliner”—a makeup artist must-have for intense pigment and performance—which needed water, a brush, and an artist’s hand to apply it. Now, Kat Von D Beauty has combined all the benefits of this iconic artistry eyeliner and put them in an easy-to-use pencil.

Clinical Results: In a consumer study on 32 volunteers, after 24 hours:
- 100% of users agreed that this product applies smoothly
- 97% of users agreed that this product did not smudge throughout the day
- 91% of users agreed that this product applies with precision and control
Size .49oz/1.4g · ITEM 2208486
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$19.00

yay its permanent!!...really happy this is now permanent.
What it is: An ultra-black, retractable, jumbo pencil that glides on creamy, and provides plenty of play time for quick and easy, long-lasting smoky eyes.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This creamy pencil glides smoothly across lids, laying down intense-black pigment along the way, in iconic shade Trooper Black. Best of all, once it sets, it’s smudge-resistant for unstoppable, long wear.

Clinical Results: In a consumer study on 30 volunteers over 24 hours:
- 97% of users agreed this product is highly pigmented
- 90% of users agreed this product has extreme long wear
- 90% of users agreed this product delivered fast and foolproof smoky eyes
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 1051325
COLOR: Stash [ 27 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

i love...Love <3...I have been using this eyeliner in about 5 different colors for 2 yrs and have never found one better it literally does not run or smudge no matter how much you cry or sweat I get questions constantly on what brand I use and am always proud to say UD 24/7...FINALLY THIS PENCIL IS AMAZING I WEAR MY EYELINER ON MY WATER LINE IT GLIDES ON AND STAYS ON ALL DAY YOU WILL NEED A GOOD WATER PROOF MAKE-UP REMOVER TO REMOVER THIS GREAT LINER
What it is:
A dynamic eyeliner pencil in a rainbow of shades.

What it does:
Glide on color that stays put. Urban Decay's cushiony, creamy eye pencils delivers powerful, vibrant color that slides on smooth and stays soft and creamy for blending (about 30 seconds), then dries to a long-lasting finish that won't budge. Line eyes with a hint of color or go for the full artistic, multi-hued effect.

What else you need to know:
Created with 50 percent moisturizing ingredients suspended in a sophisticated waterproof formula, this brilliant collection of eye essentials offers long-lasting color and a dreamy, creamy feel when applied.

This product is an Allure Best of Beauty award winner.