Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Color Eye Pencils.

Browse the top-ranked list of Color Eye Pencils below along with associated reviews and opinions.

Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 1531516
COLOR: Black Violet [ 2 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$25.00

I got Black Gold...best of its kind...great color but doesn't last...I usually wear Chanel waterproof eye pencils, but when I saw this one by LM, I fell in love with the color: Black Turquoise
Kohl Eye Pencil has a thicker diameter and is formulated specifically for lining the inside of the eyelid, at the base of the lashes.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 2083442
COLOR: Overdrive [ 1 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

I love this liner...They are very nice...Double life is a nice color for accent....In the picture I am attaching, I used only this product and a less dramatic mascara to show the color on myself and the versatility of using it as an eye pencil
What it is:
A 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in three new shades that pair perfectly with Born To Run Eyeshadow Palette’s neutral to smoky and bright to sultry eye looks.

What it does:
Keep the adventurous vibes going with three fun-loving shades of Urban Decay’s 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. From a reddish-brown to a dark copper to a deep green metallic, these versatile shades will pair perfectly with any bold eye look you can dream up (each sold separately).

UD’s Born To Run 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils are your globe-trotting go-to. These two new shades and one cult-favorite (Lucky) are the perfect complements to any Born To Run eye look. Made with UD’s award-winning, waterproof formula, these creamy pencils will stand up to dancing until daybreak in Prague or long drives through the Mojave Desert. The shades make a sunset-hued eye a cinch and offer enough playtime to smudge for an imperfect wing that sets and stays put.

Like all 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencils, these Born To Run shades feature shade-matched barrels (convenient when you’re trying to dig the right pencil out of the depths of an overnight bag).

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens

What else you need to know:
Urban Decay is 100 percent cruelty-free.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 2235752
COLOR: Wildside [ 1 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

I love these pencils...I love this eyeliner...) Such a beautiful color!...Caught my eye as "limited edition" so I knew I had to try it
What it is: An award-winning, long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner pencil in a wide range of shades.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. This product is also cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil applies super-soft for blending, then dries to a long-lasting finish. Line eyes with a hint of color or opt for a dramatic, multi-hued look. The waterproof formula contains 50-percent moisturizing ingredients, making this a holy grail eyeliner that’s a dream to apply.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g · ITEM 2131662
COLOR: Love Drug [ 1 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

I'm so glad I did...I love this liner...Such a pretty color!...I purchased Black Market UD eye pencil because I wanted to darken my lash line without going too stark
What it is:
An award-winning eye pencil in two new shades that pair perfectly with your Naked Cherry eye looks.

What it does:
Intensify your Cherry eye look with two all-new eyeliner shades in Urban Decay’s award-winning, waterproof formula. Love Drug is a deep, metallic wine shade, and Black Market is a rich, black with a satin finish (each shade sold separately). Both look amazing as winged liner or on your tightline.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens
- Sulfates
- Phthalates

What else you need to know:
This formula is cruelty-free.
Size 0.05 oz/ 1.6 g · ITEM 2389583
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$20.00

So loving this pencil...Staying power is great...Great color but doesn't last...When I found this one I had to try , I'm obsessed it's seriously the best shade I could have hoped for makes the eyes look bigger and ugh just LOVE it
What it is: An effortless, multi-use pro matte pencil that is Mario’s go-to tool for brightening eyes of every skin tone.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is cruelty-free, and gluten-free.

What Else You Need to Know: Mario uses this multitasking pencil to open the eyes, brighten, and add light to the inner corners, tear ducts, and along the waterline. He also applies it to define and highlight under the brow bone. The soft and blendable formula glides on smoothly with exceptional grip and neutralizes redness around the eyes.
Size 0.04 oz · ITEM 1744283
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$22.00

it worked for me...I really like it...Love the colors...I only apply it on my top lashline as I am not a fan of under eye make up for myself, so that could be why others say they have raccoon eyes
What it is:
A creamy, waterproof, demi-matte eye pencil specifically designed for gliding along the inner rim of the waterline.

What it does:
Urban Decay’s creamy, demi-matte 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil lays down waterproof color in a range of never-before-seen shades. Created for use along the inner rim in the waterline (and fully legit), this pencil is even creamier than Urban Decay’s original bestselling 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. It glides on easily and goes anywhere you want to put it. Once the color sets, it won’t budge so you can perfectly line your waterline in classic black, or opt for a colorful shade—like navy or green—for an eye look that really stands out.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens

What else you need to know:
So you can easily tell the difference between 24/7 Eye Pencil and 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil, Urban Decay gave 24/7 Waterline a shade-matched ombré gradient that fades to black, with a matte black cap and end. This product is free of mineral oil, paraffin, and preservatives.
Size .056 oz · ITEM 2102465
COLOR: Champagne Diamonds [ 7 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$27.00

I love the color...So easy to apply...I can't wait to try out different colors!...The color is nice and shimmery....That being said, after testing this product and wearing it a few times... I do have to say, I am so pleased with this Color Chameleon Eye Shadow Pencil that I will most likely purchase a couple more shades
What it is:
An easy eye-color-enhancing pencil that smudges and sets.

What it does:
Charlotte Tilbury's eyeshadow pencil is designed to enhance eyes by complementing specific eye colors. It is a hybrid product that can be used as a shadow or liner. The smooth, easy-glide formula is infused with synthetic sapphire, whose mineral, soft-focus effects transform and enhance eye color for a range of looks that can be dialed up or down depending on the occasion. The formula lasts for up to 10 hours and is waterproof, so when applying be sure to blend quickly!

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens
Size 0.18 oz/ 5 g · ITEM 1118819
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$23.00

WOW an eye opener...I love the colors...I really love the shimmery color but that matte is just whatever....but the shimmer makes it worth it....I knew highlighting above and below was supposed to give more definition to the brow but I'm fair skinned and didn't know for sure on the color....I loved the color and the fact that is rose-y but also has the shimmer side which looks great as an eyeshadow looks very natural when highlighting the brow and defining it the only reason I give it 4 stars is because the consistency is a little bit too thick for miami weather but I absolutely LOVE it excellent purchase
What it is:
A double-ended matte and shimmer brow highlighter.

What it does:
This silky Anastasia Highlighting Duo Pencil features a matte highlighter on one end and a shimmer highlighter on the other. Use the matte side during the day to create a soft highlight, and for evening looks, use the shimmer side to give eyes that soft, satiny glow. It’s formulated with vitamin E and features light-diffusing pigments that even skin tone.
Size 0.04 oz/ 1.41 g · ITEM 2072353
COLOR: 604 Up & Down Tan [ 26 more colors ]
exclusive· limited edition· buzzworthy· online only
$20.00

Yes it is smooth...I love the color...Gorgeous color for lips!...I took a star off because I find it obnoxious that I have to use a pencil sharpener to get a tip, but I like it enough that I bought 2
What it is: A first-of-its-kind pencil for lips, eyebrows, eyeliner, blush, or contouring, with the versatility to create any look.

What Else You Need to Know: Line eyes and lips, contour, fill in brows and more—all with this pencil. Available in 39 intense shades to be worn individually or layered, these richly-pigmented, matte pencils glide on smoothly and blend seamlessly. A precise design gives you control to create whatever you want, wherever you want.