Cream Color Eyeliner

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Cream Color Eyeliner.

Cream-colored eyeliner is a versatile and game-changing beauty product that deserves a spot in every makeup lover's collection. With its creamy texture and intense pigmentation, this type of eyeliner effortlessly glides on the lids, creating precise lines and stunning eye looks. Whether you prefer a classic cat-eye, a bold graphic design, or a brightening effect from the waterline, cream-colored eyeliner offers endless possibilities to enhance and define your eyes.

KVD BeautySuper Pomade Vegan Eyeliner, Shadow & Brow Pigment

ITEM: 2226769

Color: Auburn

4.1K Reviews

$34.00

Buy Now

Ive been using this for years in all colors. I love using it as a base for eyeshadow! This color is perfect for a natural eyeliner. ...BEST cream eyeliner!!...Ok, so I have tried various pot cream eyeliners and even a stick cream eyeliner, and NOTHING worked.

What it is: A one-pot wonder for waterproof eyeliner, shadow, and brows in a range of long-lasting colors, from vivid, playful hues to essential, versatile shades.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: Experience smooth, creamy, long-wear color with this three-in-one vegan pomade that lets you unlock endless possibilities. Use it like a gel-pot eyeliner, bold cream eyeshadow, brow pomade, and more. Super Pomade is the same beloved KVD Super Brow formula with even more ways to get creative.

Clinical Results: In a consumer study on 32 volunteers over 24 hours:
- 96% would recommend Super Pomade
- 96% agree it has instant payoff
- 96% agree it feels weightless

PATRICK TAMajor Dimension Precision Gel Eyeliner

Size: 0.007 oz/ 0.2 g·ITEM: 2463974

Color: Cream - soft cream

776 Reviews

$38.00

I was sent the cream color to try out and personally, I just don't love the color on me as much but anyone that likes a lighter shade on will love this. ...The cream color makes for a great waterline color for brightness, and dries matte!

What it is: A creamy eyeliner that gives full coverage with one swipe and sets to a bulletproof finish.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This eyeliner has the highest concentration of pigment in a soft base for full payoff and extended wear in one swipe. It provides the glide and the coverage of a liquid in pencil form.

Iconic LondonSmokey Eye Duo Kajal Eyeliner + Eyeshadow

Size: Chunky 0.02 oz, Precision 0.007 oz/Chunky 0.85 g, Precision 0.2 g·ITEM: 2698918

Color: Juniper Green - a royal, rich green that is the perfect match for green or hazel eyes

58 Reviews

$34.00

Perfect eyeliner...I purchased chocolate brown and love it, doesn’t smudge, long lasting, I’ll be purchasing the other colors...Wow, my favorite eyeliner!...I got the chocolate color, i will get it in more colors. Highly recommended!

What it is: A dual ended long-wear cream eyeshadow and eyeliner crayon that is provides intense color while being creamy and blendable.


Highlighted Ingredients:

- Intense Coated Pigments: Ensure a long-lasting color payoff that won’t stop giving until you do.

- Translucid Film Forming Polymer: Sets the liner in place, providing long wear that stays for up to 24 hours.

- The High Crystalline Wax Blend: Allows formula to buff and blend,before it ‘sets’ in place.


Ingredient Callouts: This product is cruelty-free.

DIORDiorshow On Stage Crayon Kohl Liner

ITEM: 2669687

Color: 254 Blue - An electric blue

36 Reviews

$45.00

Great eyeliner...I’m very picky with eyeliners but found this eyeliner to be great. It’s creamy so it glides easily and you can use the smudge to refine as needed....INDUSTRIAL GRADE CREAM EYELINER...I have two of these and this is the only eyeliner to have stayed in my water line. It is super pigmented and creamy, and long lasting.

What it is: A waterproof kohl pencil eyeliner that enhances the eyes with intense, blendable color for spectacular smoky eye looks.

What Else You Need to Know: The waterproof eyeliner stays put for couture eye makeup looks that last all day. Combining intense color with a creamy, buildable texture, this formula makes it easy to create a stunning smoky eye.

Anastasia Beverly HillsDarkside Waterproof Gel Matte Eyeliner

Size: 0.01 oz/ 0.28 g·ITEM: 1820414

Color: Darkside

64 Reviews

$24.50

I neeeeeeeeeeeded an eyeliner dark enough to pop and this did the job. I hate eyeliners that are dull. ...Great, long-lasting eyeliner!...This liner is better than most of all the other (drawer full) eyeliners I have used. My eyes water a lot and most others are gone by lunchtime no matter how heavy, I apply.

What it is:
A waterproof, black gel eye pencil that lasts.

What it does:
This ultra-pigmented gel cream pencil instantly creates bold, sultry eye looks. Its slim, retractable tip glides effortlessly over your upper and lower lash lines. This waterproof formula won't fade, crease, or smudge, leaving smooth, precise, and liquid-like lines.

Urban Decay24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil Space Cowboy

Size: 0.04 oz / 1.2 g·ITEM: 2814713

Color: Space Cowboy - light champagne gold with silver sparkle

30 Reviews

$31.00

The sparkle & the color is perfect. You can wear alone, use all over the lid or just as an eyeliner, or pair with eyeshadow. ...What I dislike about the Urban Decay Eyeliners is that you have to sharpen the eyeliners and that Urban Decay strategically sells an eyeliner sharpener…powerplay.

What it is: A bestselling luxury eye pencil that glides on ultra-creamy and delivers long-lasting eyeliner looks that won’t smudge—now in viral shade, Space Cowboy.

Highlighted Ingredients:
- Vitamin E
- Jojoba Oil
- Cottonseed Oil

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. It is also vegan, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.

What Else You Need to Know: The Space Cowboy eyeliner gives you a warm shimmery nude liner in the same 24/7 formula—so you get a smooth application without dragging or pulling. Once dry, this eyeliner pencil is waterproof and smudge-proof for up to 16 hours of wear. Try it and see why it’s the number-one luxury eye pencil.

SEPHORA COLLECTIONIntense Felt-Tip 12HR Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner

Size: 0.09 oz / 2.8 g·ITEM: 2761492

Color: 03 Forest Green - deep green

150 Reviews

$19.00

I got this is two colors: brown and green, both look beautiful....One of the best eyeliners...The blue color is nice and popping and it did last me all day.

What it is: Felt-tip, waterproof liquid eye liner. Intensely pigmented in satin and metallic finishes. Long-lasting to get you through your day.

What Else You Need to Know: Just one swipe of this gel-ink formula gives intense, long-lasting color in satin or metallic finishes. Ultra-precise felt-tip applies waterproof color smoothly. No pulling, skipping, or tugging on eyelids. Not tested on animals.

stilaMini Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Size: .008 oz / .25 ml·ITEM: 2580769

Color: Black - intense black

76 Reviews

$18.00

Give us more colors, Stila!...I wish Stila offered minis in more colors since my full size eyeliners usually dry out before I finish them....I found the intense black color was not so intense. The full-size Stila eyeliner was easier to use and a better color.

What it is: An easy-application, travel-size, waterproof liquid liner that stays on all day and night.

What Else You Need to Know: This travel-size, easy-glide, quick-dry precision liner stays in place until you say when—no smudges, feathering, or running. The thin, marker-like tip is easy to use, even for the beauty beginner, and delivers any look—from a thin line to a bold, dramatic stroke.

Urban Decay24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil - Naked Cherry Collection

Size: 0.04 oz/ 1.2 g·ITEM: 2131670

Color: Black Market - rich black satin

60 Reviews

$31.00

Great color!...Out of the box color for me but I love it. Urban Decay eye liners are the best....It is my favorite color so far! Very soft and feminine color. The application is wonderful as always like UD's other eyeliner.

What it is:
An award-winning eye pencil in two new shades that pair perfectly with your Naked Cherry eye looks.

What it does:
Intensify your Cherry eye look with two all-new eyeliner shades in Urban Decay’s award-winning, waterproof formula. Love Drug is a deep, metallic wine shade, and Black Market is a rich, black with a satin finish (each shade sold separately). Both look amazing as winged liner or on your tightline.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens
- Sulfates
- Phthalates

What else you need to know:
This formula is cruelty-free.

Products related to Cream Color Eyeliner

Light Brown Eyeliner
“I got the burgundy color and it really helps my light brown eyes pop! I want more colors”
Golden Brown Eyeliner
“I usually don’t splurge on eyeliners but since this one came in brown I had to”
Yellow Eyeliner
“It goes from a bright yellow gold, to an antique/burnt orange, to a neon green, (similar to VR Fire Opal from Pat’s Bronze Seduction”
Light Pink Eyeliner
“I did receive this as a free sample through Influenster, but that does not affect my opinion. The metallic pink was lost on my fair skin with pink undertones”
Pastel Eyeliner
“I might not wear this color often but it is a very soft light blue that adds a vibrant flair. Super fun to play around with this color and style an outfit around”
Orange Eyeliner
“It’s really long lasting and amazing for the price point (compared to other eyeliners at Sephora) Really the only downside is the packaging gets kind of messy, but it’s nothing major”
Light Blue Eyeliner
“Honestly I'm emotional just thinking about it. I currently own light blue, gold and I used to own the light pink one”
Periwinkle Eyeliner
“I don't ever really gravitate to blueish colors but u had to get the periwinkle one and I LOVE it. It's gorgeous. I will deff be checking out the other colors”
Pearlescent Eyeliner
“I do love HausLabs in general. And yes their eyeliners are quite amazing, longwear for sure and just love the way it looks with eyes and you can create interesting looks with it”
Light Pink Cream Eyeshadow
“The pillow talk color of this eyeshadow cream is fantastic! It’s a perfect neutral pink that compliments my skin tone”

Related Content:

Best Eye Creams of 2024, Professional Spa Tools for Men, Best Eyebrow Makeup in 2025, Perfume & Perfumes for Women, Best Face Highlighters in 2025, Pore Minimizing Products, Best Foundations for Oily Skin in 2024, Professional Beauty Tools, Best Products for Dry Hair in 2025