If you're looking for a safe, natural way to brighten your eyes, look no further than clean eye makeup. The right shade can help you look more awake and refreshed. Here are some of the best clean eye makeup options for sensitive eyes.

Size: 0.27 / 8·ITEM: 2335198
Color: After Midnight - Soft Black
$40.00
For Sensitive Eyes...I think it’s worth the $$ because it lasts for awhile and looks so natural and doesn’t mess with my sensitive eyes!...This mascara is incredible. I have extremely sensitive eyes that makes it hard to find a good mascara that doesn't burn and irritate my eyes.
What it is: An award-winning clean mascara that lengthens, lifts, and separates—now in a new brown shade. Safe for sensitive eyes.
Formulation Type: Volumizing and Lengthening
Benefits: Long-wearing
Highlighted Ingredients:
- Arginine and Biotin: Powerful lash-care heroes that help strengthen and fortify.
- Organic Shea Butter: Weightlessly conditions and adds a soft, flexible feel.
- Ethically Sourced Beeswax: Nourishes and defines lashes without clumping.
Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.

$40.00
This mascara is great for sensitive eyes. I love that it is made with clean ingredients and it doesn’t smudge or irritate my eyes....Great for sensitive eyes...It doesn't smudge or flake, and best of all, it doesn't irritate my sometimes sensitive eyes. It lasts me all day and is easy to remove.
What it is: A clean volumizing mascara that wraps each lash in weightless, buildable volume without flaking, smudging, or irritating sensitive eyes.
Formulation Type: Volumizing
Highlighted Ingredients:
- Arginine: Supports stronger, healthier-looking lashes.
- Provitamin B5: Nourishes to promote thicker-looking lashes.
- Weightless Wax Blend: Adds full, flexible body without the weight.
Ingredient Callouts: This product is cruelty-free.

ITEM: 2368504
Size: 0.13 oz / 4 mL
$20.50
I have dry, sensitive eyes, so it's hard for me to find a product that works well and doesn't contribute to irritation. ...This product looks great, but I see none clean bunny 🐰 🐇 or any of the other way to show cruelty free or organic.
What it is: A mascara that gives lashes instant and long-lasting volume, length, and lift with an exclusive "Load, Comb, and Lift" technology brush.
Highlighted Ingredients:
- Lash-Lifting Polymer: Lifts and holds lashes.
- Carnauba Wax and Microcrystalline Wax: Add body and texture to the formula for volume and length.
- Kerestore™: Creates a super-strong conditioning effect on individual hair fibers to create a thicker look and feel on lashes.

$41.00
Great mascara....my eyes are just rude....It went on beautifully and looked stunning....buuuut my eyes just hated it. So, if you don't have sensitive eyes, absolutely worth trying. ...This mascara gives instant volume and is easy to use- no raccoon eyes here! I have incredibly sensitive eyes and have no irritation whatsoever with this, which is incredibly rare.
What it is: An intensely black, ultra-dramatic mascara.
Benefits: Volumizing
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: This mascara’s custom double-cut brush loads your lashes and combs through for the ultimate volume, lift, and definition, while peptides and glycerin help condition and support healthy-looking lashes.

Size: 0.21 oz·ITEM: 2753937
Color: 04 POETRY - a poem composed by a dusty pink with a hint of billiard green.
$100.00
The whole experience of opening the palette, utilizing the interior mirror, and selecting from the included colors is such a special experience. I have sensitive eyes and skin, and each of these eyeshadow colors worked wonderfully for me. ...I wore this palette on my eyes before a night out, with NO eye primer...and my eye makeup still stayed on the entire night!!!!
What it is: An eye palette, inspired by the iconic prints from the house archives, with a unique set of three sophisticated neutrals and a single eccentric accent shade.
Highlighted Ingredients:
- Plukenetia Volubillis Oil: Helps make formula creamy and blend easily.
What else you need to know: This refillable eyeshadow palette is an invitation to explore all your dimensions and experiment with endless combinations of easy-to-wear, easy-to-dare eye looks. Created using a low-pressure injection process with Micro-Pixel™ pigments, this eyeshadow delivers one-stroke color payoff with high color resolution. The hybrid creamy-powder finish blends without fallout and provides weightless comfort.

Size: 0.11 oz / 3.12 g·ITEM: 2855310
Color: Space Cowboy Intense - bronze shimmer
$36.00
The pigmentation is vibrant with a bold metallic finish, and the formula is fragrance-free, making it comfortable for sensitive eyes. Its packaging is compact and practical with a twist-up applicator, though some may find it hard to control. ...It doesn’t crease and last throughout the day. Doesn’t bother my sensitive eyes.
What it is: A beginner-friendly, crease-resistant liquid shadow with a built-in brush for a long-wearing, glazed and glowing eye look in seconds.
What Else You Need to Know: The glaze and glow with this liquid shimmer eyeshadow includes a built-in brush for easy application. The buildable shades include two duo chrome and four shimmer shades for versatility.

Size: 0.21 oz/ 6 g·ITEM: 1956465
Color: Black - rich black
$36.50
For reference, I have oily lids and sensitive eyes and this mascara doesn't irritate my eyes. ...Doesn’t irritate my sensitive eyes. Easily applies. Good product overall.
What it is:
A revolutionary conditioning mascara to flaunt a faux lash look.
What it does:
Grande Mascara lets you get the faux lash look with your own natural lashes. This exclusive, rich-black mascara not only provides extreme length and volume, but it’s infused with lash-loving blend of peptides, panthenols, and natural waxes to condition lashes while you coat and promote healthier-looking, longer lashes over time.

$34.00
Feels lightweight and comfortable, did not irritate my semi-sensitive eyes. It did fade and crease by the end of the day, but I honestly haven’t come across an eye primer that hasn’t with my semi-hooded eyelids. ...definitely does what it say and doesnt irritate my sensitive eyes. i love that it’s formulated to be used on the under eyes. my only complaint is i wish this had some sort of color to it so i could see how much i’m applying
What it is: An invisible, hydrating primer for eyeshadow and under-eye concealer that smooths skin and locks down color to prevent creasing, fading, and smudging.
Finish: Natural
Skin Type: Normal, Oily, Dry, Combination
Highlighted Ingredients:
- Blue Agave Extract: Helps form an invisible layer to lock in makeup.
- Hyaluronic Acid and Hemp-Derived Cannabis Seed Extract: Boost hydration for delicate eyelid and under-eye area.
- Niacinamide (Vitamin B3) and Aloe Water: Provide additional moisture and antioxidant benefits.
Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.

Size: 0.01 oz / 0.28 g·ITEM: 2648012
Color: Oil Slick - gunmetal shimmer, brush tip
$38.00
Beautiful application, not good for sensitive eyes...Just inevitably ruining my eye makeup...) For me, that makes it not worth it. ...However, it caused my eyes to burn after a few months. Not for sensitive eyes unfortunately
What it is: A vegan liquid eyeliner that has an ergonomic grip, is water- and smudge-resistant, wears all day, and comes in a range of vibrant colors.
Ingredient Callouts: It is cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: This eyeliner comes in a ‘flow-through’ pen component with felt and brush tips, making it easy to create a variety of eye makeup looks. Shake the eyeliner and then create, whether a natural-, winged- or advanced graphic liner-look. The patented, ultra-sharp tip glides on smoothly to accentuate any eye shape.

Size: 12 x .05 oz/12 x 1.3 g·ITEM: 2906071
$110.00
The Ethereal Eyes Eyeshadow Palette: Nature brings together warm, organic tones that mirror the calm and glow of nature. ...The Ethereal Eyes: Nature Palette by Makeup by Mario is a gorgeous eyeshadow palette with beautiful earthy tones.
What it is: A new palette, inspired by the power of nature’s seasonal renewal, with 12 universal neutrals and four finishes to create ultimate versatile looks.
Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, mineral oil, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, sulfates SLS & SLES, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. These products are also vegan and cruelty-free.
What Else You Need to Know: This limited-edition palette is Mario’s artistic vision come to life with sunlit earthy tones found in nature at its most magical. The shades provide light, buildable coverage and are blendable, long-wearing, and versatile. This palette is









