Get 4X Points†† on ALL Makeup! Ends 3/4. ††Exclusions/terms apply. Use code MAKEUPMATH ▸

Sign Infor FREE Shipping

Natural Makeup For Brown Eyes

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Natural Makeup For Brown Eyes.

If you have brown eyes, you're in luck: There are plenty of products out there that can help you look more awake and alive. From liners to pencils to gels, here are some great options for natural makeup for brown eyes.

tartefake awake™ waterproof gel eyeliner highlight

Size: 0.007 oz/ 0.21 mL·ITEM: 1900984

Color: Universal Nude

424 Reviews

$33.00

Buy Now

This fake awake eye highlighter is perfect! It helps to open up my eyes and make me appear more awake! ...It applies so beautifully and makes my eyes look so awake and brighter. It really makes the eye area look more open and highlighted.

What it is: A tug-proof gel eyeliner in a universally flattering nude and white highlighter shade.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, phthalates, mineral oil, sulfates SLS & SLES, and triclosan. It is also cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This product is vegan, dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, and is safe for contact lens wearers.

tartesex kitten eye definer liquid eyeliner

Size: 0.047 oz/ 1.4 mL·ITEM: 1961069

Color: Black

670 Reviews

$33.00

I just wish it came in dark brown!...I love love love this eyeliner it is everything no smears does not fade out it is everything and goes every where with me this is a must have in your makeup bag <3 and to top it off its organic products i love tarte

What it is:
A waterproof, smudge-proof, precise liquid eyeliner for a bold cat eye look that lasts all day.

What it does:
It gives intense, alluring payoff that’s foolproof, thanks to a super skinny felt tip design that deposits an even, steady stream of pigment that lasts for 12 hours.

PradaDimensions Multi-Effect Refillable Eyeshadow Palette

Size: 0.21 oz·ITEM: 2753952

Color: 06 PULP - organic apricot shades enveloped with a reinvented pink.

689 Reviews

$100.00

Moreover, the hues look fantastic on my dark brown eyes! definitely recommend...So impressed! Beautiful on brown eyes!...You cannot make a whole eye look with this, but the shades are different enough that I truly believe it’s a must have eyeshadow pallete to add to your collection.

What it is: An eye palette, inspired by the iconic prints from the house archives, with a unique set of three sophisticated neutrals and a single eccentric accent shade.

Highlighted Ingredients: 
- Plukenetia Volubillis Oil: Helps make formula creamy and blend easily.


What else you need to know: This refillable eyeshadow palette is an invitation to explore all your dimensions and experiment with endless combinations of easy-to-wear, easy-to-dare eye looks. Created using a low-pressure injection process with Micro-Pixel™ pigments, this eyeshadow delivers one-stroke color payoff with high color resolution. The hybrid creamy-powder finish blends without fallout and provides weightless comfort.

Urban Decay24/7 Inks Easy Ergonomic Liquid Eyeliner Pen

Size: 0.01 oz / 0.28 g·ITEM: 2647972

Color: Hi-Energy - blue shimmer, brush tip

1.4K Reviews

$38.00

I wish it was more pigmented as it sometimes requires multiple passes, but the color itself enhances brown eyes very well. It will not be water resistant on oily lids but it's much easier to remove than waterproof products. ...Gunmetal is a pretty gray color that is perfect for those with light brown eyes like mine! I prefer gunmetal over hi-energy, which is more of a blue color that’s too harsh for my eyes.

What it is: A vegan liquid eyeliner that has an ergonomic grip, is water- and smudge-resistant, wears all day, and comes in a range of vibrant colors.


Ingredient Callouts: It is cruelty-free.


What Else You Need to Know: This eyeliner comes in a ‘flow-through’ pen component with felt and brush tips, making it easy to create a variety of eye makeup looks. Shake the eyeliner and then create, whether a natural-, winged- or advanced graphic liner-look. The patented, ultra-sharp tip glides on smoothly to accentuate any eye shape.

Urban Decay24/7 Glaze-On Shimmer Liquid Eyeshadow

Size: 0.11 oz / 3.12 g·ITEM: 2855286

Color: Sunshine Tax - pink to gold duo chrome

671 Reviews

$36.00

I enjoyed this for a night out makeup look. It’s definitely very shimmery but adds sparkle to your eyes. ...[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] I am obsessed with not only the packaging but the product! This eye shadow is perfect for us natural makeup girls.

What it is: A beginner-friendly, crease-resistant liquid shadow with a built-in brush for a long-wearing, glazed and glowing eye look in seconds.


What Else You Need to Know: The glaze and glow with this liquid shimmer eyeshadow includes a built-in brush for easy application. The buildable shades include two duo chrome and four shimmer shades for versatility.


KulfiUnderlined Kajal Clean Waterproof Long-Wear Eyeliner

Size: .01 oz / 0.3 g·ITEM: 2609220

Color: Nazar No More - black

537 Reviews

$29.00

Purple is THE BEST eyeliner color for brown eyes, AKA me, and this is such a wonderful shade! ...A beautiful purple shade that looks gorgeous on brown eyes (and all eyes!). The formula is creamy and glides on the skin very smoothly so it is perfect for everyday use.

What it is: An ultra-smooth, waterproof, smudgeproof, drag-proof eyeliner with intense, long-lasting color that doesn't budge.


Highlighted Ingredients:

- Aloe Vera Extract: Ensures a creamy glide and drag-proof application.

- Vitamin E: Moisturizes and acts as a free-radical fighting antioxidant.

ILIALimitless Lash Lengthening Clean Mascara

Size: 0.27 oz / 8 g·ITEM: 2850378

Color: Before Dawn - rich brown

5.3K Reviews

$40.00

I haven’t used brown mascara for my brown eyes before. This is perfect colour and gentle to my eyes. ...Give brown a try...I did receive the brown as a full Size sample to try. I have brown eyes and really liked the look of brown it’s a softer look from jet black.

What it is: An award-winning clean mascara that lengthens, lifts, and separates—now in a new brown shade. Safe for sensitive eyes.

Formulation Type: 
Volumizing and Lengthening


Benefits: Long-wearing


Highlighted Ingredients: 
- Arginine and Biotin: Powerful lash-care heroes that help strengthen and fortify.

- Organic Shea Butter: Weightlessly conditions and adds a soft, flexible feel.

- Ethically Sourced Beeswax: Nourishes and defines lashes without clumping.


Ingredient Callouts: This product is gluten-free, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.

HourglassCaution™ Extreme Lash Mascara

ITEM: 2087666

Size: Standard Size Black - 0.33 oz/ 9.4 g

2.8K Reviews

$48.00

I love how bold it makes my brown eyes look!!! Lasted all day!...And it's possible to take it off with just water which I love, as my eyes get very irritated with eye makeup removers.

What it is:
An all-in-one mascara that delivers a look of endless length, intense volume, and sky-high lift for extreme, dramatic lashes.

What it does:
Caution Extreme Lash Mascara’s smooth, buildable, ultra-black formula creates dramatic but weightless lash looks that don’t smudge or flake. The 4DAmplifier™ brush combines two brushes in one to deliver volume, length, lift, and definition for extreme lash looks. It saturates lashes with product from root-to-tip for the most volume in a single stroke, and perfectly coats the bottom lashes without smudging onto the lower lash line. The tapered end reaches even the smallest lashes in the corners of the eyes.

This product is vegan and cruelty-free.

tarteTarteist™ Pro Cruelty-Free Lashes

ITEM: 2156412

Type: Heartbreaker - wispy, 3-dimensional flutter

445 Reviews

$21.00

Very Natural...I loved these lashes. They look natural and are a mix of brown...Definitely recommend it made my eyes pop out.And normally they don’t because I have brown eyes so it’s kind of not noticeable but these lashes made them look amazinggg

What it is: A single set of vegan false lashes with a clear comfort-fit, cotton strip.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens, phthalates, and latex. This product is also vegan and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: Tartiest™ Pro Cruelty-Free Lashes are available in many styles:

Sassy: Wispy, full, and fluffy.
Wifey: Flirty volume with V-shaped clusters.
GTL: Natural yet dramatic flutter.
Girl Boss: Layered dimension and length.
Goddess: Big, bold drama.
Center of Attention: Tapered length and volume.
Baddie: 3D, full-flutter.
Glamazon: 3D, extreme volume.
Heartbreaker: 3D length and wisp.

Grande CosmeticsGrandeMASCARA Conditioning Peptide Mascara

Size: 0.21 oz/ 6 g·ITEM: 1956465

Color: Black - rich black

600 Reviews

$36.50

Perfect for everyday, natural look. My eyes are pretty sensitive so I find a lot of mascaras are itchy/uncomfortable -- this one is not itchy at all, doesn't flake, and gives very pretty natural volume!...Every mascara gives me raccoon eyes.. and I wore this on a windy day and my eyes started tearing and no raccoon eye!!

What it is:
A revolutionary conditioning mascara to flaunt a faux lash look.

What it does:
Grande Mascara lets you get the faux lash look with your own natural lashes. This exclusive, rich-black mascara not only provides extreme length and volume, but it’s infused with lash-loving blend of peptides, panthenols, and natural waxes to condition lashes while you coat and promote healthier-looking, longer lashes over time.

Products related to Natural Makeup For Brown Eyes

Natural Makeup For Green Eyes
“These liners are tremendous but especially the plum color (1999) really makes green eyes POP. Love it”
Natural Eye Makeup
“Gifted by MilkMakeup: This under eye brightener is AMAZING! If you want to get that dewy natural everyday look this is definitely the under eye concealer for you, make sure to get yours right in time for summer to get that summer glow with milk cosmetics”
Light Brown Eye Makeup
“Left side is great for day time but can be used to smoke out a brown eye look which looks amazing with blue eyes”
Dark Brown Eye Makeup
“around outer corners WHAT I LIKE:  * Soft, creamy consistency * Goes on smoothly * Blends easily (those with oily lids should prime & set lids first) * One of the better kohl liners I've used to do a smokey eye. That said, there are some extra steps I need to take to minimize or manage smudging (see below). * Love the taupe shade - it’s not a color I see often; a nice hue between an earthy mushroom brown and stone grey that makes for a soft smokey eye look. ”
Lavender Eye Makeup for Brown Eyes
“Looks amazing on light skin (redhead, transparent skin, brown eyes). I can honestly say it’s my favourite eyeshadow palette right now”
Eyeliners For Brown Eyes
“The best eyeliner Wow I’m impress!!! the best eyeliner that i tryed goes smooth and is long lasting I love it also I ordered in brown”
Warm Brown Makeup
“Not to soft not to hard not to waxy just right! I got the warm brown shade and it was too warm for my preference I definitely need to pick up a neutral dark brown instead”
Purple Makeup for Brown Eyes
“I use the matte pink + brown shade everyday and the glitter for some pizazz”
Makeup For Brunettes With Green Eyes
“The Laura Mercier Caviar Eyeshadow stick in Amethyst is amazing! It makes green eyes pop. The stick is easy to use and blend while also having staying power”
Brown Smokey Eye Makeup
“One of the most unique eyeliners I've tried. If you have brown colored eyes, you need this! This shade truly makes my eyes pop like no other”

Related Content:

Best Hair Products For Dry Hair, Best Eyebrow Makeup in 2025, Best Products for Dry Hair in 2025, Best Eye Creams of 2024, Best Foundations for Oily Skin in 2024, Best Face Moisturizers, Best Brow Products For You | Brow Quiz, Best Affordable Makeup in 2025, Best Colognes for Men in 2024