eyeliners for oily lids

I additionally have slightly oily lids so it's hard for me to find something that stays on for a long time even with a primer. ...Best cobalt blue eyeliner <3...It is highly pigmented, glides easily on the lids, wears well on oily skin throughout the day and did not irritate my sensitive skin.

What it is:
A waterproof, pigment-rich khol eyeliner in vibrant shades with smudge-proof wear.

What it does:
Available in six vibrant shades, Khol Couture Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner is enriched with intense color pigments. Its long-wear formula resists humidity and glides seamlessly onto your lids. Its retractable pencil means application is precise and fast, and its comfortable and smooth texture allows for all day wear. The array of colors is designed to interplay with the seasons to define eyes year-round.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens

What else you need to know:
The pencil is equipped with a built-in sharpener to provide a precise tip at all times.

It didn't flake off or smudge to create raccoon eyes; I have oily-ish lids but I did use an eyelid primer. I didn't use the brush part of this pencil so I can't speak to how it works but I wouldn't say it was long wearing, high coverage, or very pigmented....not for oily hooded eyes.....Transfers to upper lid on me. However I have tried many smudge proof liners and have never ever found one that doesn’t transfer.

What it is:
An eyeliner pencil that combines the creamy bendability of a kohl, with the intense, high coverage, long wearing pigment of a gel.

What it does:
Ciaté London’s Wonderwand Gel-kohl Eyeliner Pencil is built to give you a number of liner options. Create a precise line for defined perfection, or smudge it out using the built-in blending brush for a more sultry, smoked-out eye look. Its unique, hybrid formula performs like a kohl because it’s incredibly easy to apply and remains smudgeable long enough for you to blend it out as desired. Once it sets, it provides the longevity and staying power of a gel.

What it is formulated WITHOUT:
- Parabens
- Sulfates
- Phthalates

Very black and long lasting, even with watery eyes and oily lids this stays put! The applicator is different, but the packaging is very nice. ...easy-peasy eyeliner...It has this tiny little wheel that you just place on your lid and roll out. It seems to last all day and stays in place.

What it is:
A revolutionary rollerball that glides ink on for easy, straight, smooth eye-lining.

What it does:
Never use eyeliner? This easy eyeliner ink is for you. It's as simple as Rock (shake) ’n’ Roll (draw). Rock N' Roller Easy Eyeliner Ink is perfect for drawing graphic, straight, or curved lines every time. Liquid lining has never been so easy to control. Easily achieve eye-lining perfection with this high-pigment, sweat-proof, smudge-proof, waterproof liner that stays put all day. The ultra-fine rollerball glides across the lash line for precise ink application, allowing you to create a variety of looks with ease. The ink dries down matte, but never flat.

It's very black, which is great, BUT it transfers all over your lid. It does not glide on smooth, it always skips over my minimal eye shadow and as it smears, it makes my eye lids sticky. ...Not for your water line! Great for upper lid wear.

What it is: A waterproof, ultra-black, ultra-thin felt tip eyeliner. Create a precise, long-lasting line in just one smooth stroke.

What Else You Need to Know: Waterproof eyeliner lasts up to 12 hours. Ultra-thin felt tip to create a tight line that adds definition to your eyes. Use alone for a fine line or to add more definition to a smoky eye.

Doesn’t last on my lids....It is worth noting I struggle to find eyeliners that last in the waterline and don't struggle with finding eyeliners that last just on the lid.

What it is: A long-wearing, waterproof eye pencil in a range of high-intensity, ultra-pigmented shades.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. This product is also vegan, cruelty-free, and gluten-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This versatile, creamy formula effortlessly glides on, allowing for a precise application and enough playtime to blend and smudge. Create a bold wing or use it as an eyeshadow base—there are endless ways to play.

Although the ultimate dealbreaker was it’s weak lasting formula. I have oily skin and after 4-5 hours, I don’t have any wing definition and barely any product left on my lids…...I've been using eyeliners like this for around 10 years, and this is my favorite I've ever found!

What it is: A creamy, long-wear eyeliner pencil for bold definition.

What Else You Need to Know: These rich, creamy, waterproof eyeliners glide on smooth and set to a transfer-resistant matte finish. It features an automatic, no-sharpen tip and a built-in smudger for smoky eyes in seconds and is available in four shades that flatter everyone.

I wear liquid liner daily and this is the BEST one I’ve tried hands down. It stays on oily lids all day at work, and has great pigment. ...I was hoping it last long since I was looking for a liner for oily lids.

What it is: A super-precise felt-tip applicator for intense-pigment color payoff and long wear—in a innovative design and formula.

What Else You Need to Know: Feline Flick Volume 2 liner helps you achieve Charlotte’s signature feline flick cat-eye look easily with its extra-soft fiber tip that applies like a brush. The color glides on and sets quickly to avoid feathering and smudging and stays on for up to 12 hours—but comes off easily using eye-makeup remover.

Good for Lid - not waterline...This eyeliner is great for the lid - smooth, creamy, easy to apply. ...It does smudge a bit with oily lids but holds over at least 6 hours before I start seeing that

What it is: A vegan and waterproof precision gel liner that glides on effortlessly.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This liner is made with soft-melting gel with a natural wax blend, ensuring a smooth, easy glide that never skips, tugs, or drags on delicate eyelids. Its feather-light sealing film locks the formula down for lasting wear. The ultra-precise tip with built-in sharpener gives the perfect line, every time.

Clean at Sephora
Clean at Sephora is formulated without a list of over 50 ingredients, including sulfates (SLS and SLES), parabens, phthalates, and more. For the full list, check out the Ingredients tab.

A combination of hooded and oily eyelids have made finding a smudge proof eyeliner nigh impossible, until now. ...Stays all day, the ink flows well from the brush tip (not felt tip), and I can draw a sharp cat eye every time. Stays well on oily lids, even when I accidentally rub my eyes.

What it is: A mistake-proof pen liner with all the drama of a liquid eyeliner without the drama of putting it on.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance. It is also vegan, gluten-free, cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging.

What Else You Need to Know: CLINIQUE's mistake-proof pen creates a clean line in one steady sweep. The tapered, ultrafine precision brush paints on pure, deep color both thin and thick. The High Impact™ Easy Liquid Liner offers up to 24-hour smudge and budge-resistant wear. It is ophthalmologist-tested and appropriate for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

I purchased this to tightline and line the upper lid/lash. Waterline performance: lasted a good 4-5 hours with minimal fading. ...Watery eyes or oily eyelids ? It’s a no....If you have dry eyes or don’t have any issues with eyeliners specifically for the waterline, definitely get these, but I don’t recommend for oily eyelids or watery eyes.

What it is: A nude-toned eyeliner that provide a bright, wide-eyed effect for the waterline and creates opaque coverage in one gentle swipe without tugging.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens. It is also gluten-free and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This ultra-creamy pencil can be used as cream shadow. It is easy to blend all over your eyes, and once it is set, it won't smudge. This eyeliner is also transfer resistant with up to 10 hours of wear.