Preppy Eye Makeup

Sephora customers often prefer the following products when searching for Preppy Eye Makeup.

Achieve a classic and polished look with our collection of preppy eye makeup products. Whether you're going for a subtle everyday style or a sophisticated evening glam, we have everything you need to create stunning eye looks. From neutral eyeshadow palettes to precise liquid eyeliners and volumizing mascaras, our range of preppy eye makeup essentials will help you define, enhance, and accentuate your eyes effortlessly. With high-quality formulas and versatile shades, you can easily achieve the timeless elegance that amazing eye makeup is known for. Explore our selection and elevate your eye game to new levels of chicness.

ILIAMini Limitless Lash Lengthening Mascara

Size: .1 oz/ 3g·ITEM: 2217933

Color: After Midnight - black

2.6K Reviews

$18.00

I recommend it to anyone who wants a clean classy lash look....creamy, classy and clean....Preppy good!

What it is: A buildable, flake-free mascara that lengthens, lifts, and curls for more voluminous lashes.

Highlighted Ingredients:
- Shea Butter: Conditions and protects against irritation.
- Beeswax: Coats and lengthens the look of lashes with soft flexibility and hold.
- Keratin: Fortifies and promotes healthy lashes.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is cruelty-free and gluten-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This lightweight, nourishing formula contains beeswax and carnauba wax to weightlessly condition your lashes. Shea butter and keratin fortify to enhance and nourish the look of lash condition. A dual-sided brush allows you to define, lift, and separate lashes with precision.

LancômeLash Idôle Lash-Lifting & Volumizing Waterproof Mascara

Size: 0.27 oz/ 8mL·ITEM: 2516136

Color: 01 Glossy Black - black

486 Reviews

$40.50

And, to top it off, it lasted for hours! The packaging looks posh I love it....Classy and long lasting

What it is: A lash lifting, waterproof mascara that targets every single lash for instantly longer, thicker, and more lifted lashes with no clumps.

Formulation Type:
Volumizing, Lengthening

Benefits: Long-wearing, Waterproof

What Else You Need to Know: This mascara has up to 24 hours of waterproof wear and pushes up lashes for an eye-opening effect to create fully fanned-out volume with no flakes. The lightweight formula doesn’t weigh on lashes so it’s comfortable all day and is the perfect mascara for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers.

Clinical Results: In a consumer test realized on a panel of 103 women:
- 95% saw instant lash lift
- 94% saw instant volume
- 90% saw clump-free lashes

ValentinoEye2Cheek Eyeshadow and Blush

Size: 3.6 g·ITEM: 2542348

Color: 04 Sweet Rebel - warm rose with light reflecting pearls

518 Reviews

$70.00

Unique color with classy shimmer...It has a touch of lavender that makes it entirely unique, along with subtle and classy shimmers. I love that I can use it on both my cheeks and eyes. ...The color is super soft and slightly shimmery, I like to take my finger and dip it and then apply on my eyelids for a little color when I don’t want to do a whole eye makeup look. It’s super cute for inner corners of the eyes too.

What it is: A versatile cream-to-powder blush and eyeshadow that creates a visibly radiant finish from eye to cheek with buildable coverage and a lightweight feel.

What Else You Need to Know: This two-in-one eyeshadow and blush has a creamy, sheer finish that can be layered for a more intense color impact. The buildable formula is infused with Valentino's signature Roma-Light Complex™, crafted with color-boosting pearls for a highlighted, visibly radiant skin finish.

Yves Saint LaurentCouture Mini Clutch Eyeshadow Palette

Size: 0.17 oz / 5 g·ITEM: 2789469

Color: 700 Over Noir - cool chromes

397 Reviews

$92.00

Typically love all YSL products. Very classy and love all the colors. Highly recommend....I love the packaging, it's so posh. I received the palette in the 100 Store Dolla shade, and it is a perfect eyeshadow for a date night, as I always go for a chic, nude, casual style.

What it is: A couture eyeshadow quad featuring four eyeshadows with high pigment payoff and a soft, oil-enriched formula for up to all-day wear.

Highlighted Ingredients:
- Coffee Seed, Sweet Almond, and Fig Cactus Oils: Add soft texture and long-lasting yet gentle staying power.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of formaldehydes, formaldehyde-releasing agents, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, triclocarban, triclosan, and contains less than one percent synthetic fragrance.

What Else You Need to Know: A couture eyeshadow quad with four luxurious shades for edgy sophisticated looks, encased in an exquisite, quilted palette. Satin, matte, metallic, and shimmer finishes apply smoothly for up to all-day wear. Enriched with pre

$38.00

Classy...They’re very easy to apply a gives the eyes a slight dramatic look, nothing over powering....They looked natural and very posh.

What it is:

A kit with everything you need to apply your first pair of false eyelashes with no measuring, no trimming—just glue and go.


What Else You Need to Know:

Comfortable, lightweight, natural-looking false lashes for everyday wear. They can be used 25+ times. The White Latex-Free Lash Adhesive is a non-irritating formula that is perfect for lash beginners. The Too Easy Lash Applicator allows for precise and easy lash application.


This set contains:

- Would I Lie? (subtle and elegant, this fluttery natural lash is our go-to for both work and play!)

- Mini Latex-Free Lash Adhesive (dries clear)

- Mini Too Easy Lash Applicator

Westman AtelierEye Want You Lengthening + Volumizing Clean Mascara

Size: 0.29 oz·ITEM: 2699213

Color: Le Brun Clean - brown

389 Reviews

$61.00

One layer is just enough for light makeup days. The tube looks classy and is easy to find in my enormous bag. ...Packaging, so posh, can't deny, Heavy tube, substantial supply.

What it is: An endlessly buildable mascara that lengthens, defines, and volumizes for a natural-to-bold lash, with a clean, pigment-rich, and flake-free formula.

Formulation Type:
Volumizing, Curling

Highlighted Ingredients:
- Carnuaba and Candelilla Wax Blend: Ultra-creamy texture for maximum build.
- Shea Butter: Nourishes and protects lashes.
- Plant-Dervied Ester: Rich pigment payoff, boosts wear time.

Ingredient Callouts: This product is vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: Ultraclean, safe ingredients for the delicate eye area. A plant-based wax blend delivers nourishing length and volume without clumping, flaking, or transferring. Go natural to bold—in just a fe

TOM FORDEye Defining Pen Liquid Liner Duo

Size: .03 oz/ .8 mL·ITEM: 1987635

Color: 01 Deeper - black

2K Reviews

$85.00

I love this eye pen. It’s so great. Looks very posh. I will buy it again when this is done. ...Honestly probably too smooth because it runs into my eyes and doesn’t stick. I love the packaging and the feel (the weight and materials are very posh) of it.

What it is: A dual-ended liquid eyeliner with a fine calligraphy tip on one end, and brush on the other for a range of sleek to dramatic effects.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of sulfates, parabens, and fragrance.

What Else You Need to Know: Formulated in the blackest shade of black, this dual-ended liquid liner delivers ultimate precision and makes fluid strokes easy to achieve. With a fine calligraphy tip on one end and a brush tip on the other, it creates a spectrum of transforming effects, from classic, sleek lines to dramatic wing-tips or a sultry, doe-eyed effect.

Too FacedDisco Crush High Shine Glitter Eye + Face Sparkle

Size: 0.05 oz / 1.42 g·ITEM: 2794493

Color: Mystic Pink - petal pink with gold sparkle

24 Reviews

$41.00

I bought the shades Mystic Pink and Heart Eyes; absolutely beautiful shades and swatched against my huge collection of multi chromes they still feel special and nuanced, with a larger glitter particle size...preppy...I'm so excited to use this!!! yayyy this so so preppy!

What it is: A creamy, dimensional eyeshadow and face glitter with unique reflective qualities and intense sparkle for a hyper-pigmented wet-look shine.

Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens and mineral oil. It is also gluten-free and cruelty-free.

What Else You Need to Know: This lightweight and comfortable formula offers one-swipe smooth and creamy application. The multi-dimensional light shifting formula gives a high-intensity sparkle and a hyper-pigmented wet-look shine. It’s also multi-use for face and eyes.

Products related to Preppy Eye Makeup

Preppy Makeup
“Kristen has a pretty preppy pink kind of look and the lip plumper added in the gloss is perfect”
Classy Eye Makeup
“I really love this reflector for the eye area! Beautiful gold color with the right amount of shimmer to make the eyes pop”
Modern Eye Makeup
“The shimmer definitely brings out the depth in brown eyes. Very easy to use with agreeable pencil tip and light frame”
Orange Eye Makeup
“Product comes off easily with makeup remover. Highly recommend. Doesn’t irritate my sensitive eyes”
Easy Eye Makeup
“This eyeliner from IT Cosmetics is perfect for someone who tends to always get uneven lines, struggles with line's shape, or is a beginner in makeup. It is really simple to use and requires no special skill to end up having a perfect eye makeup. ”
Gold Eye Makeup
“I also have the 2 Frozen Gold color that is also pretty and can be used as a highlighter”
Soft Pink Eye Makeup
“The tones that are unique to this palette are perfect - the soft pink shimmer nails the bridal pink look every time”
Light Eye Makeup
“The shimmer is striking and really makes my brown eyes stand out. So easy to control while applying and quick”
Glamour Eye Makeup
“I love pink and sparkly stuff, sue me, sometime I just want to be a barbie doll. This product is a glamour sparkly extravaganza of just that. Its SUPER glittery”
Blue Eye Makeup
“Every blue eyeliner I’ve tried in the past will either disappear throughout the day, or smear making my eye makeup look like a disaster but for me this pencil is game changing”